Our Land, Our Water, Our Elections

Judge Rules for Landowners in Groundwater Export Dispute

Share on Google+Share on LinkedInTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • We are more than excited to share this long overdue news for Texas landowners and their rights to protect the aquifers beneath them -- Happy New Year, Texas! (read the release below)
  • Note: If you live in the Lost Pines District (Lee and Bastrop counties) please plan to be at the next Lost Pines Groundwater Conservation District Meeting on Wednesday, January 17th, likely starting at 7 pm at Bastrop City Hall. (We will keep you informed).
  • Also, this coming Monday, at 9 am, please attend the Bastrop County Commissioner's Court Meeting (Bastrop County Courthouse) where the subject of a Waste Transfer Station planned for high-growth Cedar Creek will be on the agenda.

For Immediate Release
Thursday, January 4, 2018

SIMSBORO AQUIFER WATER DEFENSE FUND (SAWDF)
P.O. Box 690
Elgin, Texas 78621-0690
www.simsborowaterdefensefund.org
~~Working for a legacy of aquifers that last forever~~

Contacts:  Michele Gangnes 512-461-3179 mggangnes@aol.com

                   Travis Brown 512-560-0341  travisbrown983@gmail.com

Judge Rules for Local Landowners In Groundwater Export Dispute  

BASTROP – A state district judge in Bastrop has ruled in favor of four local landowners in a dispute over permits that allow massive amounts of groundwater to be pumped from Lee and Bastrop counties.

Judge Carson Campbell’s January 4, 2018 order (copy here) ruled that the Lost Pines Groundwater Conservation District improperly excluded three individual landowners and conservation group Environmental Stewardship, also a landowner, from participating as parties in a 2014 hearing over permits issued by the district in 2016 to water marketing company End-Op LP, now known as Recharge Water.

Those permits allow Recharge Water to pump and export up to 46,000 acre-feet of water annually (approximately 15 billion gallons per year) from 14 wells in the Simsboro formation of the Carrizo-Wilcox Aquifer, for export to Hays, Travis and Williamson counties.

The judge’s ruling also revokes the permits issued by the groundwater district to Recharge Water and orders the district to conduct new proceedings on the permits that allow the four landowners to participate as parties.

“Judge Campbell’s ruling sets an important precedent for all of Texas,” said Michele Gangnes, a Lee County attorney and director of the Simsboro Aquifer Water Defense Fund. “It means groundwater districts must recognize the property rights of all landowners in their groundwater and give them a voice on pumping permits that likely will affect the groundwater under their land.”

Gangnes said a new hearing before an administrative law judge over the Recharge Water permits would also allow the landowners to present evidence that the pumping allowed by those permits would permanently damage the viability of the Simsboro formation.

“Pumping of that scale, especially when combined with other planned Simsboro projects, would cause huge drawdowns, affecting the wells and groundwater resources of thousands of landowners across Lee and Bastrop counties,” Gangnes said.

In a new hearing, Environmental Stewardship also would present evidence that the pumping would have negative impacts on the rivers, streams and springs that depend on groundwater. "Our objective is to protect and sustainably manage the Colorado River, its tributaries and our aquifers, through monitoring and practices based on good science," said Steve Box, Executive Director of Environmental Stewardship.

”While the district may side with End Op and appeal Judge Campbell’s ruling to a state court of appeals,” said Ernest Bogart of Elgin, one of the landowners’ attorneys, “we hope the district will accept this ruling that will allow the district’s constituents and all Texans to protect their property and water rights.”

During a hearing before Judge Campbell on Oct. 18, attorneys for the groundwater district and Recharge Water argued that the landowners had no right to be parties because none of them had wells that were producing water from the Simsboro formation.

“The judge’s ruling affirms our position that whether you have a well or not is irrelevant – your groundwater resources would be impacted by these pumping permits and you as a landowner have the right to be heard,” Gangnes said.

SAWDF was formed in 2016 by veterans of several groups, including Neighbors for Neighbors, who have battled for almost two decades to protect the region’s groundwater. SAWDF, a 501(c)(3) organization, has focused its current fundraising campaign on supporting the landowners’ case.      

                                                ####

 

Share on Google+Share on LinkedInTweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook

5 comments

  1. Sitting in during this hearing was very instructive about the lack of control that people have over there own property. Texas allows a kind of water capture domination to our watersheds, which is not only bad public policy, but could create functional deserts. Thanks so much for your efforts to raise awareness. I will watch what happens down the road.

    1. Thanks so much, Tim! We are grateful to have you show up even though you live in Austin — we love all our Austin pals!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *